Colin’s Choice by Dorene Meyer

Colin Hill is a young man faced with many choices. He is being pressured into a career choice that doesn’t feel right to him, and he is in love with someone who is not ready to fully return that love. Most difficult of all, Colin must choose to revisit his past – the painful past he has tried so hard to forget. 

But young Bobby Peters is missing. Evil from the past overshadows the old cabin, and Colin fears they may already be too late.